| 4th Quarter Play-by-Play |
| Shep | 1-10 | on Rock43 | Start of 4th quarter, clock 15:00. |
| Shep | 1-10 | on Rock43 | PENALTY SHEP holding (Chandler Brown) 10 yards to the SHEP47. |
| Shep | 1-20 | on Shep47 | Tyson Bagent pass complete to Daryl Harper for 37 yards to the ROCK16, 1ST DOWN SHEP (Jacob Williams). |
| Shep | 1-10 | on Rock16 | Tyson Bagent pass incomplete to Daryl Harper. |
| Shep | 2-10 | on Rock16 | Ronnie Brown rush for 1 yard to the ROCK15 (J. Dangerfield). |
| Shep | 3-9 | on Rock15 | Tyson Bagent pass complete to EJ Morgan for 5 yards to the ROCK10 (Selvin Haynes). |
| Shep | 4-4 | on Rock10 | Jacob Haynie field goal attempt from 28 GOOD, clock 12:34. |
| Shepherd 30, Slippery Rock 20 |
| | Drive: 12 plays, 81 yards, TOP 6:13 |
| | | Jacob Haynie kickoff 35 yards to the ROCK30, Derian Green return 8 yards to the ROCK38 (Donnell Howard). |
| Rock | 1-10 | on Rock38 | SLIPPERY ROCK drive start at 12:29. |
| Rock | 1-10 | on Rock38 | Noah Grover pass complete to Cohen Russell for 1 yard to the ROCK39 (Terrell Lindsey). |
| Rock | 2-9 | on Rock39 | Noah Grover pass complete to Jawon Hall for 6 yards to the ROCK45. |
| Rock | 3-3 | on Rock45 | Chris D'Or rush for 4 yards to the ROCK49, 1ST DOWN ROCK (Devon Lynch). |
| Rock | 1-10 | on Rock49 | Noah Grover pass incomplete to Kyle Sheets. |
| Rock | 2-10 | on Rock49 | Cohen Russell rush for 4 yards to the SHEP47 (Keyshawn Hailey). |
| Rock | 3-6 | on Shep47 | Noah Grover pass complete to Gavyn Barnes for 8 yards to the SHEP39, 1ST DOWN ROCK (Nathan Muhle). |
| Rock | 1-10 | on Shep39 | Noah Grover pass complete to Cohen Russell for 14 yards to the SHEP25, 1ST DOWN ROCK (Terrell Lindsey). |
| Rock | 1-10 | on Shep25 | Chris D'Or rush for 22 yards to the SHEP3, 1ST DOWN ROCK (Klayton Batten). |
| Rock | 1-G | on Shep03 | Isaiah Edwards rush for no gain to the SHEP3 (Kyle Smith). |
| Rock | 2-G | on Shep03 | Tim Smith rush for 2 yards to the SHEP1 (Devon Lynch). |
| Rock | 3-G | on Shep01 | Noah Grover rush for 1 yard to the SHEP0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 07:13. |
| | | DJ Opsatnik kick attempt good. |
| Shepherd 30, Slippery Rock 27 |
| | Drive: 11 plays, 62 yards, TOP 5:21 |
| | | Kyle Butts kickoff 61 yards to the SHEP4, Alphonso Foray return 18 yards to the SHEP22 (Kam Kruzelyak). |
| Shep | 1-10 | on Shep22 | SHEPHERD drive start at 07:08. |
| Shep | 1-10 | on Shep22 | Timeout Slippery Rock, clock 07:08. |
| Shep | 1-10 | on Shep22 | Ronnie Brown rush for 3 yards to the SHEP25 (Brandon Bischof). |
| Shep | 2-7 | on Shep25 | Tyson Bagent pass complete to Rodney Dorsey for 10 yards to the SHEP35, 1ST DOWN SHEP (Selvin Haynes). |
| Shep | 1-10 | on Shep35 | Ronnie Brown rush for 19 yards to the ROCK46, 1ST DOWN SHEP (B. Tuck-Hayden). |
| Shep | 1-10 | on Rock46 | Tyson Bagent pass complete to Kenneth Edelin for 7 yards to the ROCK39 (Ali Abdul-Hakim). |
| Shep | 2-3 | on Rock39 | Ronnie Brown rush for 13 yards to the ROCK26, 1ST DOWN SHEP (Eddie Faulkner). |
| Shep | 1-10 | on Rock26 | Tyson Bagent pass incomplete to Alphonso Foray. |
| Shep | 2-10 | on Rock26 | Tyson Bagent pass complete to Rodney Dorsey for 2 yards to the ROCK24 (B. Tuck-Hayden). |
| Shep | 3-8 | on Rock24 | Tyson Bagent pass incomplete to Ryan Beach. |
| Shep | 4-8 | on Rock24 | Tyson Bagent pass complete to Rodney Dorsey for 14 yards to the ROCK10, 1ST DOWN SHEP (Kevin Hyde). |
| Shep | 1-G | on Rock10 | PENALTY SHEP holding (Ty Lucas) 10 yards to the ROCK20. |
| Shep | 1-G | on Rock20 | Ronnie Brown rush for 3 yards to the ROCK17 (J. Dangerfield). |
| Shep | 2-G | on Rock17 | Timeout Slippery Rock, clock 02:15. |
| Shep | 2-G | on Rock17 | Tyson Bagent rush for no gain to the ROCK17 (D.J. Adediwura). |
| Shep | 3-G | on Rock17 | Tyson Bagent pass complete to EJ Morgan for 17 yards to the ROCK0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 01:43. |
| | | Jacob Haynie kick attempt good. |
| Shepherd 37, Slippery Rock 27 |
| | Drive: 12 plays, 78 yards, TOP 5:31 |
| | | Jacob Haynie kickoff 42 yards to the ROCK23, Cohen Russell return 4 yards to the ROCK27 (Naeem Watson). |
| Rock | 1-10 | on Rock27 | SLIPPERY ROCK drive start at 01:37. |
| Rock | 1-10 | on Rock27 | Noah Grover rush for 8 yards to the ROCK35. |
| Rock | 2-2 | on Rock35 | Noah Grover pass incomplete to Kyle Sheets. |
| Rock | 3-2 | on Rock35 | Chris D'Or rush for 13 yards to the ROCK48, 1ST DOWN ROCK (Keyshawn Hailey). |
| Rock | 1-10 | on Rock48 | Noah Grover pass complete to Chris D'Or for 6 yards to the SHEP46 (JT Kouame-Yao). |
| Rock | 2-4 | on Shep46 | Noah Grover pass complete to Cohen Russell for 21 yards to the SHEP25, 1ST DOWN ROCK, out-of-bounds. |
| Rock | 1-10 | on Shep25 | Noah Grover pass complete to Bryce Profitt for 16 yards to the SHEP9, 1ST DOWN ROCK, out-of-bounds. |
| Rock | 1-G | on Shep09 | Noah Grover pass intercepted by Terrell Lindsey at the SHEP0, Terrell Lindsey return 0 yards to the SHEP0, touchback (EJ Morgan). |
| | Drive: 7 plays, 64 yards, TOP 0:50 |
| Shep | 1-10 | on Shep20 | SHEPHERD drive start at 00:47. |
| Shep | 1-10 | on Shep20 | TEAM rush for loss of 1 yard to the SHEP19. |
| Shep | 2-11 | on Shep19 | Timeout Shepherd, clock 00:40. |
| Shep | 2-11 | on Shep19 | TEAM rush for loss of 1 yard to the SHEP18. |
| Shep | 3-12 | on Shep18 | End of game, clock 00:00. |
| | Drive: 2 plays, minus 2 yards, TOP 0:47 |
