| 1st Period Play-by-Play |
| [15:00] | Mike Dizonno at goalie for BW-M. |
| [15:00] | Matt Niemi at goalie for OTT. |
| [15:00] | Faceoff Keller Fisher vs Mike Roman won by OTT, [15:00] Ground ball pickup by OTT Mike Roman. |
| [14:53] | GOAL by OTT Xander Seal (FIRST GOAL), Assist by Mike Roman. |
| Otterbein University 1, Baldwin Wallace 0 |
| [14:53] | Faceoff Keller Fisher vs Mike Roman won by OTT, [14:53] Ground ball pickup by OTT Mike Roman. |
| [14:09] | GOAL by OTT Joe Sanfillipo, Assist by Drew McDonald. |
| Otterbein University 2, Baldwin Wallace 0 |
| [14:09] | Faceoff Nicholas Nanosky vs Mike Roman won by OTT, [14:09] Ground ball pickup by OTT Justin McKee. |
| [13:00] | Ground ball pickup by OTT Connor Dziewit. |
| [12:43] | Shot by OTT Chandler Swartz WIDE RIGHT. |
| [12:31] | GOAL by OTT Connor Dziewit. |
| Otterbein University 3, Baldwin Wallace 0 |
| [12:31] | Faceoff Jake Mostyn vs Mike Roman won by OTT. |
| [11:35] | GOAL by OTT Drew McDonald. |
| Otterbein University 4, Baldwin Wallace 0 |
| [11:35] | Timeout by BW-M. |
| [11:35] | Faceoff Jake Mostyn vs Mike Roman won by BW-M. |
| [10:38] | Shot by BW-M Mike Nanosky WIDE RIGHT. |
| [10:38] | GOAL by BW-M B. Riemenschneider, Assist by Chad Steinwachs. |
| Otterbein University 4, Baldwin Wallace 1 |
| [10:38] | Faceoff Jake Mostyn vs Mike Roman won by OTT, [10:38] Ground ball pickup by OTT Mike Roman. |
| [10:24] | Turnover by OTT Mike Roman (caused by Matthew Rodenhouse). |
| [10:18] | Ground ball pickup by BW-M Matthew Rodenhouse. |
| [10:22] | Penalty on OTT Charlie LaShell (PUSHING/0:30) Extra-man opportunity. |
| [09:58] | Turnover by BW-M Chad Steinwachs. |
| [09:50] | Clear attempt by OTT good. |
| [08:36] | Shot by OTT Xander Seal WIDE RIGHT. |
| [08:25] | Shot by OTT Chandler Swartz, SAVE Mike Dizonno. |
| [08:14] | Clear attempt by BW-M failed. |
| [08:02] | Turnover by BW-M Derek Andrews. |
| [07:49] | Turnover by OTT Connor Dziewit (caused by Matthew Rodenhouse). |
| [07:46] | Ground ball pickup by BW-M Brian Jandzinski. |
| [07:36] | Clear attempt by BW-M good. |
| [07:10] | GOAL by BW-M Derek Andrews. |
| Otterbein University 4, Baldwin Wallace 2 |
| [07:10] | Faceoff Jake Mostyn vs Mike Roman won by BW-M, [07:10] Ground ball pickup by BW-M Jake Mostyn. |
| [06:18] | Shot by BW-M Matt McDowell HIGH. |
| [06:05] | Clear attempt by OTT good. |
| [05:28] | Turnover by OTT Drew McDonald (caused by Alex Juhasz). |
| [05:25] | Ground ball pickup by BW-M Alex Juhasz. |
| [05:20] | Shot by BW-M B. Riemenschneider, SAVE Matt Niemi. |
| [05:14] | Clear attempt by OTT good. |
| [05:06] | Ground ball pickup by OTT Chandler Swartz. |
| [05:05] | GOAL by OTT Chandler Swartz. |
| Otterbein University 5, Baldwin Wallace 2 |
| [05:05] | Faceoff Jake Mostyn vs Mike Roman won by BW-M, [05:05] Ground ball pickup by BW-M Carson Howatt. |
| [05:00] | Turnover by BW-M Carson Howatt (caused by Connor Dziewit). |
| [04:59] | Ground ball pickup by OTT Adam Grumman. |
| [04:57] | Penalty on OTT Connor Dziewit (OFFSIDE/0:30) Extra-man opportunity. |
| [04:38] | GOAL by BW-M Andrew Hodgens (MAN-UP), Assist by Mike Nanosky. |
| Otterbein University 5, Baldwin Wallace 3 |
| [04:38] | Faceoff Jake Mostyn vs Mike Roman won by OTT, [04:38] Ground ball pickup by OTT Justin McKee. |
| [04:19] | Shot by OTT Mike Roman, SAVE Mike Dizonno. |
| [03:48] | Clear attempt by BW-M good. |
| [03:32] | GOAL by BW-M Derek Andrews, Assist by Chad Steinwachs. |
| Otterbein University 5, Baldwin Wallace 4 |
| [03:32] | Timeout by OTT. |
| [03:32] | Faceoff Jake Mostyn vs Mike Roman won by BW-M, [03:32] Ground ball pickup by BW-M Jake Mostyn. |
| [02:42] | Shot by BW-M Ben Kubiak HIGH. |
| [02:35] | Shot by BW-M Mike Nanosky WIDE RIGHT. |
| [02:16] | Ground ball pickup by BW-M Chad Steinwachs. |
| [02:11] | Shot by BW-M Matt McDowell WIDE LEFT. |
| [01:49] | Shot by BW-M Mike Nanosky BLOCKED. |
| [01:35] | Ground ball pickup by OTT Justin McKee. |
| [01:32] | Clear attempt by OTT good. |
| [01:24] | Shot by OTT Chandler Swartz, SAVE Mike Dizonno. |
| [01:19] | Ground ball pickup by OTT Chandler Swartz. |
| [01:11] | Shot by OTT Xander Seal, SAVE Mike Dizonno. |
| [00:54] | Turnover by OTT Justin McKee. |
| [00:47] | Clear attempt by BW-M good. |
| [00:38] | Shot by BW-M Nicholas Nanosky WIDE LEFT. |
| [00:19] | Shot by BW-M Alex Binner WIDE LEFT. |
| [00:19] | Penalty on OTT Tommy Kolibash (CROSS-CHECK/1:00) Extra-man opportunity. |
| [00:00] | End-of-period. |