| 2nd Period Play-by-Play |
| | Start of 2nd period [15:00]. |
| [14:36] | Shot by BW-M Ben Kubiak HIGH. |
| [14:31] | Shot by BW-M Mike Nanosky HIGH. |
| [14:18] | Shot by BW-M Mike Nanosky, SAVE Matt Niemi. |
| [14:05] | Clear attempt by OTT good. |
| [13:15] | Shot by OTT Connor Dziewit WIDE LEFT. |
| [13:03] | Turnover by OTT Xander Seal. |
| [12:59] | Ground ball pickup by BW-M Mike Dizonno. |
| [12:55] | Clear attempt by BW-M good. |
| [12:31] | GOAL by BW-M Ethan Miller, Assist by Derek Andrews. |
| Baldwin Wallace 5, Otterbein University 5 |
| [12:31] | Faceoff Jake Mostyn vs Mike Roman won by OTT, [12:31] Ground ball pickup by OTT Justin McKee. |
| [11:29] | Shot by OTT Drew McDonald WIDE RIGHT. |
| [11:08] | Turnover by OTT Chandler Swartz (caused by Brian Jandzinski). |
| [11:04] | Ground ball pickup by BW-M Alex Juhasz. |
| [11:00] | Clear attempt by BW-M good. |
| [10:01] | Turnover by BW-M Mike Nanosky (caused by Jordan Tobler). |
| [09:57] | Ground ball pickup by OTT Jordan Tobler. |
| [09:54] | Clear attempt by OTT failed. |
| [09:53] | Turnover by OTT Jordan Tobler. |
| [09:48] | Ground ball pickup by BW-M Carson Howatt. |
| [09:47] | Shot by BW-M Ben Kubiak WIDE. |
| [09:36] | Shot by BW-M B. Riemenschneider BLOCKED. |
| [09:20] | Shot by BW-M Ben Kubiak, SAVE Matt Niemi. |
| [09:16] | Ground ball pickup by BW-M Chad Steinwachs. |
| [09:09] | Ground ball pickup by BW-M B. Riemenschneider. |
| [08:49] | GOAL by BW-M Matt McDowell. |
| Baldwin Wallace 6, Otterbein University 5 |
| [08:49] | Faceoff Nicholas Nanosky vs Mike Roman won by OTT, [08:49] Ground ball pickup by OTT Mike Roman. |
| [08:39] | GOAL by OTT Justin McKee, Assist by Xander Seal. |
| Baldwin Wallace 6, Otterbein University 6 |
| [08:39] | Faceoff Jake Mostyn vs Mike Roman won by OTT, [08:39] Ground ball pickup by OTT Mike Roman. |
| [08:31] | Turnover by OTT Mike Roman. |
| [08:29] | Ground ball pickup by BW-M Liam Oberst. |
| [08:24] | Clear attempt by BW-M good. |
| [07:56] | Shot by BW-M Chad Steinwachs, SAVE Matt Niemi. |
| [07:48] | Clear attempt by OTT good. |
| [07:35] | Shot by OTT Chandler Swartz WIDE. |
| [07:33] | Penalty on BW-M Nicholas Nanosky (PUSHING/0:30) Extra-man opportunity. |
| [07:22] | Shot by OTT Connor Dziewit BLOCKED. |
| [07:04] | Turnover by OTT Chandler Swartz (caused by Mike Dizonno). |
| [06:59] | Ground ball pickup by BW-M Brady King. |
| [06:55] | Clear attempt by BW-M good. |
| [06:48] | Shot by BW-M Alex Juhasz HIGH. |
| [06:48] | Timeout by OTT. |
| [05:45] | Turnover by BW-M Derek Andrews. |
| [05:27] | Clear attempt by OTT failed. |
| [05:26] | Turnover by OTT Matt Niemi. |
| [05:23] | Ground ball pickup by BW-M Cole McClary. |
| [05:18] | Clear attempt by BW-M good. |
| [04:32] | Turnover by BW-M Matt McDowell. |
| [04:05] | Ground ball pickup by OTT Drew McDonald. |
| [04:03] | Shot by OTT Drew McDonald WIDE. |
| [04:00] | Clear attempt by BW-M good. |
| [03:50] | Shot by BW-M Derek Andrews, SAVE Matt Niemi. |
| [03:46] | Clear attempt by OTT good. |
| [03:37] | GOAL by OTT Connor Dziewit. |
| Otterbein University 7, Baldwin Wallace 6 |
| [03:37] | Faceoff Jake Mostyn vs Mike Roman won by OTT. |
| [02:29] | Shot by OTT Joe Sanfillipo, SAVE Mike Dizonno. |
| [02:22] | Clear attempt by BW-M good. |
| [01:59] | Turnover by BW-M Chad Steinwachs (caused by Adam Grumman). |
| [01:41] | Clear attempt by OTT good. |
| [00:31] | GOAL by OTT Joe Sanfillipo. |
| Otterbein University 8, Baldwin Wallace 6 |
| [00:31] | Faceoff Jake Mostyn vs Mike Roman won by BW-M, [00:31] Ground ball pickup by BW-M Ethan Miller. |
| [00:09] | Clear attempt by BW-M good. |
| [00:09] | Timeout by BW-M. |
| [00:03] | Turnover by BW-M Ben Kubiak. |
| [00:00] | End-of-period. |